A Muslim worker sued the defendant, the Philadelphia Housing Authority, under Title VII and §1983, claiming that he was terminated from employment due to his Muslim religion and in retaliation for acting as a witness in other cases against his employer. The defendant argued that he was terminated due to his participation in several crimes, such as forgery and theft. The Court found no evidence of a connection between the inappropriate remarks that were made toward the plaintiff, and the plaintiff's termination more than a year later. Thus, in 2002, the Court granted the defendant’s motion for summary judgment.